Connect with us

News

Suing Your Own Party While Staying Inside Is An Ethical Contradiction

Published

on

By Asiwaju Kunle Kalejaye SAN

In modern politics, a troubling trend has taken root: politicians dragging their own political parties to court while stubbornly clinging to their membership cards. As a lawyer, I know the law often permits such litigation, yet legality is not the measure of morality. Viewed through the lens of political ethics, suing your own party while remaining within its ranks is a profound betrayal of trust and an exercise in self-serving contradiction.

A political party is fundamentally a voluntary association built on shared ideals, mutual sacrifice, and collective discipline. Nobody is forced to join a party. As the political philosopher Michael Walzer wrote in Obligations, “men have a prima facie obligation to honor the engagements they have explicitly made, to defend the groups and uphold the ideals to which they have committed themselves.” (Michael Walzer’s essay “The Obligation to Disobey,” )  When you sign up, you enter an unspoken moral covenant: you agree to work within the group’s culture, accept its political compromises, and fight for reform through internal persuasion rather than external coercion.

To drag that same party before a Judge is to weaponise an outside authority against your own political family. It replaces camaraderie with combat. Worse still, refusing to resign while litigating creates an untenable ethical posture. In Exit, Voice, and Loyalty, the social thinker Albert O. Hirschman explained that genuine “voice” means members “agitate and exert influence for change ‘from within,’” while “exit” is the honest recourse when one can no longer support the organization.(Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States by Albert O. Hirschman)

Advertisement

You cannot simultaneously claim to be a loyal comrade working for the party’s victory while sabotaging its cohesion, draining its resources, and handing ammunition to its rivals in open court.
If a party has truly lost its moral compass or become irredeemably unjust, the honorable path is clear: resign. Walking away preserves your integrity and signals that your conscience cannot coexist with corruption.The yoruba man will say: “Ibi tí a bá ti ń jẹ ológbò, bí a ò bá jẹ ẹ́, a kì í jókòó síbẹ̀.”(Where people are eating cat meat, if you do not eat it, you do not sit there.)

Staying inside while suing, however, suggests that the dispute is rarely about high-minded democratic ideals. More often, it is driven by naked personal ambition: a desperate bid to force one’s way onto a ballot, secure a ticket, or cling to power by judicial decree after failing to win the support of fellow members.

Furthermore, internal party politics requires negotiation and consensus-building, both of which a courtroom is ill-equipped to provide. Inviting Judges to micromanage internal affairs undermines institutional autonomy and shows contempt for the collective will. As the moral philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre observed in After Virtue, “For what education in the virtues teaches me is that my good as a man is one and the same as the good of those others with whom I am bound up in human community.”(Alasdair MacIntyre’s book After Virtue.)

In ethics, consistency matters. You cannot sit at the dinner table while trying to burn down the house. Yes, a fowl that defecates in a pot is only soiling its own casket! If a political party no longer deserves your trust, leave it. If you choose to stay, honor the bond of solidarity that membership demands. Anything else is not principled dissent. It is opportunism dressed up as morality.

Asiwaju Kunle Kalejaye SAN Eagle102.5 FM Ilese-Ijebu

Advertisement

Quote

If a political party no longer deserves your trust, leave it. If you choose to stay, honor the bond of solidarity that membership demands.  

Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *